Metallizing vs. HDG
How does metallizing compare to hot-dip galvanizing?
Like hot-dip galvanizing, metallizing is a zinc coating to protect steel from corrosion, and both provide barrier and cathodic protection to the steel below the zinc coating. Metallizing has many different names including thermal spray, flame spray, or zinc spray metallizing and is applied in accordance with the specification AWS C2.2 Recommended Practices for Metallizing with Aluminum and Zinc for Protection of Iron and Steel. Hot-dip galvanized coatings are applied in accordance with ASTM A123/A123M Standard Specification for Zinc (Hot-Dip Galvanized) Coatings on Iron and Steel Products and ASTM A153/A 153M Standard Specification for Zinc Coating (Hot-Dip) on Iron and Steel Hardware.
Differences Between Metallizing and Hot-Dip Galvanizing
One of the biggest differences between these two zinc coatings is how each coating is applied. The hot-dip galvanizing process includes removing paint, weld slag, or varnish from the steel and then cleaning it by a series of baths (caustic soda, acid, and flux) and then dipping the steel into a zinc kettle where the zinc metallurgically reacts with the steel. This creates a coating with intermetallic alloy layers as well as a free zinc layer as the outermost layer. During the hot-dip galvanizing process, the steel is completely submerged in a galvanizing kettle, which means all corners, threads, edges, and hollow sections are completely covered. Hot-dip galvanized coatings are applied in a shop setting and are independent of weather.
The metallizing process consists of an abrasive cleaning equal to NACE No. 2 or SP 10 (near-white metal finish). After the steel has been cleaned, zinc wire or powder is melted inside of a heated application gun and then combustion gases or compressed air is used to apply the zinc to the steel surface within four hours of abrasive cleaning. The temperature of the steel doesnt increase like in hot-dip galvanizing, and the coating consists mainly of a free zinc layer (no intermetallic alloy layers).
Corners, threads, edges, or hollow sections can be tough or impossible to coat using the metallizing process and depend largely on applicator skill. In addition to applicator skill, the quality of a metallized coating depends on the weather. The surface must be dry and the temperature must be at least 10°F above the dew-point. Metallized coatings can be applied anywhere as long as these conditions have been met.
The bond strength of hot-dip galvanized coatings to the base steel is approximately 3,600 psi while that of metallized coatings is 1,500 psi. In addition to bond strength or adherence, the abrasion resistance of a metallized coating is also important because if it can be easily scraped from the steel, it cannot protect the base steel. One hardness rating system uses a DPN or diamond pyramid number to rate the hardness of a material. The DPN for black steel is approximately 159. The DPN of the intermetallic alloy layers of galvanized coatings ranges from 179 DPN to 250 DPN, which means these layers are harder than the base steel and creates a coating that has outstanding abrasion resistance. The DPN for metallized coatings is that of free zinc, which is only 70, and because zinc is a soft metal, the coating can be easily damaged during assembly and use.
The coating thickness of hot-dip galvanized coatings must meet ASTM minimum requirements ranging from 1.4 to 3.9 mils depending on the thickness of the steel, although galvanized coatings are often thicker than these minimums. Metallized coatings can range in thickness from 3.3 to 8.3 mils. In addition to coating thickness, coating density is also important in terms of corrosion protection because the service life of zinc coatings is directly related to the amount of zinc actually on the steel, and not necessarily the thickness of the coating. Metallized coatings are rough and slightly porous, with a specific gravity of 6.4, compared to 7.1 for galvanizing. In Figure 1, left, you can see the differences between a hot-dip galvanized coating and a metallized coating the black spots are areas where there are voids in the coating (trapped air).
Time to First Maintenance and Cost
Hot-dip galvanized steel has been observed to last 50-75 years maintenance free in many types of atmospheric environments, including industrial, urban, marine, and rural. Estimates for the time to first maintenance of metallized coatings range from 17-22 years, depending on the environment. Cost is very important when considering which zinc-coating to utilize. Differences in initial cost can be substantial between hot-dip galvanized and metallized coatings, with hot-dip galvanizing being about half as expensive as metallizing. Over the life-cycle of the steel, due to additional required maintenance, metallizing can end up being 4-5 times as expensive as galvanizing in life-cycle costs.
Recommended Uses for Each Coating
Hot-dip galvanized coatings have been successfully applied to nearly all shapes and sizes of steel ranging from nails, nuts, and bolts to large structural assemblies, including rebar. Whether indoor or outdoor, hot-dip galvanized steel provides a long maintenance-free service life. However, there are times when metallizing is a good alternative to hot-dip galvanizing, such as when items cannot be galvanized because of size or when an on-site application is needed. Metallizing is also a good alternative to galvanizing when prevention of distortion is critical to the design of a structure. Distortion is possible when hot-dip galvanizing because stresses induced into the steel during the forming process can be relieved in the galvanizing kettle. We have discussed the similarities and differences between hot-dip galvanized and metallized coatings, the service lives of each coating, and the recommended uses for each. If you would like more information, the American Galvanizers Association has more literature, including the publications Zinc Coatings and the comparison sheet Hot-dip Galvanized Steel vs. Zinc Spray Metallizing.
© 2020 American Galvanizers Association. The material provided herein has been developed to provide accurate and authoritative information about after-fabrication hot-dip galvanized steel. This material provides general information only and is not intended as a substitute for competent professional examination and verification as to suitability and applicability. The information provided herein is not intended as a representation or warranty on the part of the AGA. Anyone making use of this information assumes all liability arising from such use.