Your search did not yield any results

Site Pages

Dr. Galv KnowledgeBase

News

My customer has heard rave reviews about galvanized rebars performance when embedded in concrete for marine applications . . . Why is HDG rebar outperforming black rebar in this particular application?

Its true that galvanized rebar outperforms black rebar in this application—the superior performance is a result of several factors stemming from zincs unique corrosion behavior. The extended performance of galvanized rebar can be correlated to a higher threshold for corrosion initiation, reduced corrosion kinetics, and a lowering of stresses induced in the concrete as a result of the mobility of zinc corrosion products.

Chemical corrosion of steel results when a voltaic cell is formed contacting the steel surface. The cell contains four basic parts: anode, cathode, electrolyte, and return current path. For this discussion, lets focus on the electrolyte. In marine applications, the electrolyte is seawater—most importantly, the chloride content of that seawater. With respect to embedded rebar in marine environments, a degree of saturation of electrolyte must be reached in order for corrosion to begin. This is referred to as the critical chloride threshold. Critical chloride thresholds are different for all metals, but the value most commonly used for black steel is 1.1 lbs/yd3. Field evaluations for bridges in marine applications performed by CTL—a contractor for the International Lead Zinc Research Organization (ILZRO)—report HDG rebar performing corrosion-free for decades in chloride environments far exceeding the black steel threshold value (see chart, facing page).

1995 Data Compiled from ILZRO Field Evaluation of HDG Rebar
Bridge/Structure NameLocationConstruction Year1975 ZE 2061977 ZE 2471982 ZE 3201992 ZE 3891994 ZC 1

Years to Date Above CI- Corrosion Threshold

PCA SlabsIL1963-1969[6]     
Boca ChicaFL1972[3]  [19] [21]
Seven MileFL1972[3]    [19]
LongbirdBermuda1952 [23]  [42][42]
FlattsBermuda19668   [28][28]
ArnesIA19677 14  [26]
MontpelierVT19713 [10]  [21]
ManicouaganQuebec19668     
Penno's WharfBermuda1964/1966/1969    [28*][28*]
Hamilton DockBermuda1966    [28][28]
RBYC PierBermuda1968    [26][26]
AthersPA1973  [8][18] [20]
Betsy RossPA1973  8   
CorapolisPA1972  9[19] [21]
HersheyPA1975  [6][16]  
OrangevillePA1974  7   
TiogaPA1974  719  

From this research, its reasonably deduced that the critical chloride threshold for galvanized steel is far higher than that of black steel, but that is only part of the reason for HDG rebars noteworthy success. In high pH environments (namely saturated calcium hydroxide solutions . . . for this discussion, wet concrete mix), zinc surfaces passivate to form a calcium hydroxyl-zincate layer. A study by Andrade and Macias showed that this passive zincate layer can reduce corrosion currents, a scientific way of measuring corrosion potential, by an order of magnitude. This result was obtained in a chloride-free suspension and the effect of chlorides on the formation of this passive layer is not fully understood. Andrade and Macias showed that chloride concentrations of 0.30.9 molars do not have an effect on the formation of the passive zincate layer, but Sergi, Short, and Page suggest that higher concentrations do; however, they do not report a threshold value. Regardless, galvanized coatings after passivation show much lower corrosion currents in bench-scale tests, equivocal to zinc losses of 1.5 ?m/yr, and a service life of 100 years for an ASTM A767 Class I coating.

Galv Rebar Element Map300
Elemental map of galvanized rebar. The corrosion products of galvanized rebar are less dense and do not build up the pressure to cause concrete spalling (unlike the dense corrosion products of bare steel). The zinc corrosion products (depicted below, in white), migrate away from the galvanized coating and disperse into the concrete matrix.

The final and, perhaps, most remarkable phenomena contributing to the superior performance of galvanized rebar deals with the actual corrosion products of the zinc coating itself. Cracking—or, in its most severe form, spalling—occurs as a result of a local increase in internal pressure due to volume increase when metal transforms into corrosion products. As steel corrodes, the voluminous products formed as part of the corrosion reaction need some place to go and pressure builds until a crack in the concrete matrix results. Continued corrosion results in the production of more corrosion products, further cracking the concrete and spalling until the article is no longer fit for service. The corrosion of zinc coated rebar occurs in a slightly different fashion. Zinc corrosion products are very small and migrate away from the surface of the rebar and into the bulk media of the concrete matrix. This can be seen in the figure, right,

This phenomenon results in a small increase in internal pressure at a much slower rate. Ultimately, this translates into a longer service life for galvanized rebar.


Was this answer helpful? YES       | NO

Are you still looking for the right answer? Ask an Expert

Comments

[Comment awaiting moderation]

[Comment awaiting moderation]

Add Your Comment